I heard Cristian Mungiu say that he lost a certain freshness from his first Palme d'Or to his second, but he gained experience. In his case, freshness was not replaced by Cathar-like certainty. Fortunately, however, Cristian Mungiu speaks of doubts, of concern about the world of undoubted Cathars in politics or in religion metamorphosed into politics, about the legacy for coming generations. As long as you make films with those who are coming in mind (or those who, as in 4, 3, 2, do not get to come into the world except to end up in a dumpster or a garbage chute) is a sign that you haven't lost your freshness.
In his first Palme d'Or, Mungiu observed the ease with which Otilia (Anamaria Marinca) answered "Yes" to her roommate Găbița's (Laura Vasiliu) request, agreeing to mediate her way to "Mr. Bebe" (Vlad Ivanov). A few moments later, in the dormitory hallway, we see her caressing a kitten, stroking and cuddling it like a baby. Towards the end of the story, after "Mr. Bebe" had done his job, exceeding his duties as a "midwife" (just as cynical as his more distant relative: "The Godmother" from Postcards with Wild Flowers), Otilia gazes for a long time at the mutilated fetus, frozen in the project (filmed by Oleg Mutu in close-up), which Găbița had just abandoned in the hotel bathroom. In great haste, she wraps it in cloths very much like a shroud and, listening without a murmur to "Mr. Bebe's" instructions, she looks for a garbage chute in a tower block and drops it into the abyss. She returns to the hotel room where she finds Găbița in the restaurant, preparing for dinner: a plate full of meats and cold cuts. "We never talk about this again!" — says Otilia. Twenty years later, in his second Palme d'Or, Mungiu talks about an "open-minded" society, where "Mr. Bebe" no longer works "illegally", and a Găbița would nonchalantly act like the titular character from Alice T. by Radu Muntean. It's not the deeds of that Bebe (now legalized) that are being chastised, but something else entirely: parental authority. We are in a Norwegian village with living standards far above the European average. It's not the children's behavior, but the parents', that is being reprimanded, judged, denounced. If the family is not "permissive" enough (to be understood as: "modernist," "emancipated," "globalist," "liberalist" enough), the children are taken en masse by the "child-centered" organization called "Child Protection." The child's word matters, not the parent's. I thought of the 1950s, when some children—believing they were doing good for the new "order" established by the force of "revolutions"—denounced their parents whose mentalities were not adjusted to "proletarian morality" (considered "new," "progressive" in relation to the "old" "bourgeois" and "infamous" mentality), when parents and all those who did not conform ended up in prison or at the Canal for "re-education." Children were decorated with medals of honor. In Mungiu's work, the Gheorghiu family's children—who express their desire to return home—receive a different kind of medal: the right to waste their time in front of the television, to listen to "modern music," to access YouTube as they please. In the late '90s, Cristian Mungiu wrote and directed the short film Zapping, a satirical and grotesque apologue on the theme of the unseen "eye" in television, the distant ancestor (though only three decades have passed) of the YouTube platform. The stakes of that short film, both amusing and unsettling, were the beginning of an adventure of recovery — and therapy — through the awareness of the written word (to discover, under the onslaught of images indiscriminately broadcast non-stop by televisions, what chronicler Miron Costin called "the most beautiful and most precious pastime: reading books"), just as Ray Bradbury's character experienced and lived it over 60 years ago in Fahrenheit 451 (the book and the film). (...)
Mungiu's films are neither "neutral" nor "indifferent." They are "conservative" not because they are, supposedly, "canned films" (tributary to clichés, devoid of feeling, lifeless, and — to the irritation of those awaiting explicit judgments — without a clear stance), but because — implicitly — they conserve what pertains to the very essence of man: the soul, but not "autonomous," rather in relation to the work of grace ("amazing grace") that holds parents and children together. And, no less, the soul, ready at any moment to be torn apart by the follies of an age thirsty for "freedom," more precisely for "freedoms," "rights," "autonomies," and "novelties." Mungiu shows us the bill. That is why he disturbs many, especially those who refuse to resort to memory, to remember (if they ever knew) that it profits a man nothing to gain the world if he loses or harms his soul. If, in other words, the spirit of man separates from grace.
Marian Sorin Rădulescu
Fragments from the article published in "FILM" magazine no. 3/2026

