In a class where students still have great difficulties with the French language, and where they are usually quite passive, a student asks a question: "Is it true that the images representing Jesus do not resemble Him?" We were talking about something entirely different. She had seen this on the internet or others had told her, I suspect neo-Protestants. She seemed somewhat shocked by the presumption. This is not the first time I've received this question; other students are more troubled by it, and come up with other theories: "Jesus was black"; "it makes no sense to represent Him if we don't know what He looks like"; "icons don't look realistic" – for example.
As written, the question seems naive, but it is not. The fact that we should recognize Jesus as the prototype of His icon, that the icon is not identical but similar to the prototype, was one of the arguments of the iconodules (defenders of the icon) during the period of iconoclasm. But what does it truly mean resemblance? Do we resemble ourselves, as God wants us to? Should the icon resemble Christ as He appeared to the apostles before, or after the Resurrection? But how to talk about this in the simplest and least abstract language possible, in an era of readily available cameras and video devices for everyone and the omnipresence of images through any phone?
I started precisely from there; from the fact that no photo resembles us perfectly, cannot replace the person, but only helps us to think about them − represents the person without exhausting all their aspects. Let alone an image representing the Son of God! Just as the words of the Gospel speak to us about Christ, but it is impossible to exhaust the story (as Saint John says at the end of his Gospel), neither does the image show us "everything," but helps us to raise our gaze. One must always strike while the iron is hot. In a few days, perhaps the question will fade, which is why I answered immediately, in broad strokes. In the next class, I will try to talk about the resemblance to the deified body. But... how? Because not every icon rises to this height. I will also try to talk about the icon as a language.
Another student asks: "If two married people discover, after some time, that they no longer love each other, can you force yourself to love?" In the class, some children come from families where parents have separated. It's difficult to talk about such topics. I spoke a little about love that needs to be cultivated, that it's not just a feeling, about how we can lose someone's love, and about the fact that love is not an obligation. God asks us to love, but we don't love by forcing ourselves to love.
At another school, we are studying the two Creation narratives of the world from Genesis – including with the help of a short video made by Catholics. Orthodox still don't do such things in French; the films made by us are either too long, or only one person (generally, a monk) is seen speaking. How to show this to a group of teenagers who already have trouble concentrating for 5 minutes on a subject? We end up talking about animals. A student says he heard from a saint that animals don't go to Heaven, and especially for that reason, we must treat them kindly. I like the conclusion, but less so the reason. I tell him about man's role in raising nature towards God, I talk about wild animals humanized by saints. And a little about the mystery of the Resurrection. Likewise, the subject remains in suspension for another time. I will re-read the wonderful text by Father Florin Florescu on this subject.
Questions: surprising, predictable, naive, profound, playful, but always worth considering. We only remember what answers a quest, what truly interests us; especially in the era of information oversaturation.
"Madam, can we not work today, but talk instead?" (It's not always possible, but discussion is also a kind of lesson.)
"Have you ever smoked? Why? At what age?" (We were talking about addictions; personal testimony is generally appreciated!)
“What does the Roman Empire mean? I've never heard of it!” (If I can complete their general knowledge, it's better for the question to come from them.)
“Are you going on strike? Why?” (A discussion about the social commitment of Christians may follow)
“Have you heard of Wittgenstein?” (I have, but that's it!)
“If God made man in His image, then does God have a gender? Is He male or female?… Sorry, Madam, I was just joking, ha ha!” (I have an entire theory about the spiritual depth of humor, but that's for another occasion.)
* * *
Questions always reveal something else: a desire to know, to understand, to show that they also know something, or simply to divert the discussion from what seems too difficult, too serious for them, from what seems to overwhelm them. However, in my opinion, all of them must be taken seriously; because they often occasion a dialogue that can lead to the opening of a window. Which is one of the best things that can happen in a religion class.
Alexandra de Moffarts
Photos by cottonbro studio / pexels.com
See also:
The Diary of a Religion Teacher from Brussels (I)
A New School Year Beginning (II)

